Skip to main content

Questioning before Answering

The other day I came across a short video in which a parent is faced with answering a unexpected question posed by her young child. I found this video amusing because, being the parent of a kindergartener, I expect to be faced with many awkward moments like this in the future. I also found it an interesting metaphor for software requirements gathering.

In the video the  parent could have answered the question a whole lot more simply has she just asked taken a moment to try to understand what the real question was, and not taken the question at face value. (I'm being purposely vague at this point in case anyone wants to watch the video.)

Most of us have been on projects where much effort has been spent in an attempt to solve a customer's stated problem, only to discover that that either:

  • The program didn't actually solve any of the customer's real problems.
  • The team didn't solve the problem that the customer wanted solved.
  • There was a much simpler solution.
I'm not suggesting that exhaustive requirements capture is the answer. Nor am I suggesting that you should not start building software until you have complete understanding of a problem. The reason that agile methods work well is that they  acknowledge uncertainty, and provide a simple path to refining understanding: evaluating working software.

Acknowledging uncertainty does not mean ignoring information. In some cases customers might not really understand what they need, and the best way for a team to progress is to take a guess based on the information they have, and iterate on a working system.  In many cases a customer will know the reason they want to do something, but may not be able to step back enough to express it. In these cases, but not trying to ask "why?" your team is ignoring information  that can help them do their work. In more cases than not, a customer can fill in the pieces of  the user story template:

As a (ROLE) I want to (DO SOMETHING) so that (REASON)

and provide insight into the problem that she wants to solve. This will save time, effort, and help the team deliver a better system.

If your team takes customer requirements statements at face value without exploring the reasons why a customer wants a piece of functionality, they aren't holding up their end of the collaboration part of agile software development. 

Had the parent in the video though to ask why the child asked the question that she did, the process of answering might have been simpler.


Popular posts from this blog

Continuous Integration of Python Code with Unit Tests and Maven

My main development language is Java, but I also some work in Python for deployment and related tools. Being a big fan of unit testing I write unit tests in Python using PyUnit. Being a big fan of Maven and Continuous Integration, I really want the  Python unit tests to run as part of the build. I wanted to have a solution that met the following criteria:
Used commonly available pluginsKeep the maven structure of test and src files in the appropriate directories.Have the tests run in the test phase and fail the build when the tests fail.
The simplest approach I came up with to do this was to use the Exec Maven Plugin by adding the following configuration to your (python) project's POM.

<plugin> <groupId>org.codehaus.mojo</groupId> <artifactId>exec-maven-plugin</artifactId> <executions> <execution> <configuration> <executable>python</executable> <workingDirectory>src/test/python</workingDirect…

Displaying Build Numbers in Grails Apps

Being a fan of Continuous Delivery, identifiable builds, and Continuous Integration: I like to deploy web apps with a visible build number, or some other way of identifying the version. For example, having the build number on the login screen for example. In the Maven/Java world, this is straightforward. Or at least I know the idioms. I struggled with this a bit while working on a Grails app,  and wanted to share my solution. There may be other, better, solutions, but the ones I found approaches that didn't quite work they way that I'd hoped.

My requirements were:
To display a build number from my CI tool, where the number was passed in on the command line. In Bamboo, for example you might configure a grails build as
-Dbuild.number=${bamboo.buildNumber} warTo only change build artifacts and not any source files.To not misuse the app version, or change the names of any artifacts.To be simple and idiomatic.I realized that that Grails itself changes the application metadata (appl…

Motivation Visibility, and Unit Testing

I've always been interested in organizational patterns (such as those in Organizational Patterns of Agile Software Development). I've recently found myself thinking a lot about motivation. I'm now reading Drive: The Surprising Truth About What Motivates Us and just finished Rob Austin's book on performance measurement. Being the parent of a three year old, I'm finding more and more that "because I said so, and I'm right" isn't too effective at home. My interests in motivation are closely related to my interest in writing software effectively. Writing software is partially a technical problem about frameworks, coding, and the like, but the harder (and perhaps more interesting) problem is how to get a group of people working together towards a common goal. Agile practices, both technical and organizational, build a framework which makes having the right amount of collaboration and feedback possible. But there's a bootstrapping process: How do yo…